V. I. SEMEVSKY VERSUS S. P. MELGUNOV: DEVELOPMENT CONCEPTS OF THE “NONPARTISAN” JOURNAL “GOLOS MINUVSHEGO” IN 1913−1916
The article studies the peculiarities of V. I. Semevsky’s work as an editor of the journal “Golos Minuvshego”. Particular attention is paid to the characteristics of his mutual relations with S. P. Melgunov as a co-editor and the description of their business correspondence regarding elaboration of the ideology of the journal. The article analyzes an attempt of creation and functioning of the “nonpartisan” edition aiming at consolidating various strata of the democratic public. It examines the structure and quality of the published materials, the problems of coverage by the journal of history of Russian social thought, an attitude toward political tasks of Russian historical journalism and involvement of young talented scholars. The authors stress the possibility of using “thick” journals as a propaganda tool of opposition intelligentsia.
Keywords: V. I. Semevsky, Golos Minuvshego, intelligentsia, historical periodicals, history of social thought, S. P. Melgunov
References:
1. Kritskiy Yu. M. Voprosy istorii russkoy obshchestvennoy mysli i revolyutsionnogo dvizheniya v Rossii XVIII – nachala XX v. v zhurnale “Golos minuvshego” v 1913−1923 gg. [Problems of history of Russian social thought and the revolutionary movement in Russia of XVIII – early XX centuries in the journal “Golos minuvshego” in 1913−1923]. Istoriya i istoriki. Istoriografi cheskiy ezhegodnik – History and Historians. Historiographic Yearbook, 1972, Moscow, 1973, pp. 78−106 (in Russian).
2. Baluev V. P. Iskrenniy i pravdivyy drug naroda: Vasiliy Ivanovich Semevskiy [A sincere and true friend of the people: Vasily Semevsky]. Istoriki Rossii XVIII – nachala XX v. − Historians of Russia in XVIII − early XX centuries, Moscow, SKRIPTORII Publ., 1996, pp. 446−485 (in Russian).
3. Baluev V. P. Liberal’noye narodnichestvo na rubezhe XIX – XX vv. [Liberal narodnik movement at the turn of XIX – XX centuries] (ed. K. F. Shatsillo). Moscow, Nauka Publ., 1995. 267 p. (in Russian).
4. Emel’yanov Yu. N. S. P. Mel’gunov: v Rossii i emigratsii [S. P. Melgunov: in Russia and emigration] (2nd ed.). Moscow, URSS Publ., 2012. 352 p. (in Russian).
5. Zaveshchaniye M. I. Semevskogo, chernovoy variant [M. Semevsky’s will, a draft]. Institut Russkoy literatury [Institute of Russian Literature (IRLI)]. F. 274. Op. 1. D. 404. L. 1−3 (in Russian).
6. Peterburgskiye vedomosti − Petersburg Vedomosti, 1892, no. 130 (in Russian).
7. Delo ob izdanii v Peterburge zhurnala “Russkaya starina” [A collection of documents about the publication of the magazine “Russkaya starina” in St. Petersburg]. Rossiyskiy gosudarstvennyy istoricheskiy arkhiv (RGIA) [Russian State Historical Archive (RSHA)]. F. 776. Op. 4. D. 342. L. 206 (in Russian).
8. Yanzhul I. I. Pis’mo V. I. Semevskomu ot 11 dekabrya 1881 g. [A letter to V. I. Semevsky written on December 11, 1881]. Arhiv Rossiyskoy akademii nauk [The Archive of Russian Academy of Sciences]. Op. 3. D. 807. L. 3 (in Russian).
9. Semevskiy V. I. Domashniy byt i nravy krest’yan vo vtoroy polovine XVIII v. [Home life and customs of peasants in the second half of XVIII century]. Ustoi – Foundations, 1882, no. 1, 2 (in Russian).
10. Uspenskiy G. I. Pis’mo V. I. Semevskomu, 1891 g. [Uspenskiy G. I. A letter to V. I. Semevsky, 1891]. Arhiv Rossiyskoy akademii nauk [The Archive of Russian Academy of Sciences]. F. 489. Op. 3. D. 711. L. 1 (in Russian).
11. Semevskiy V. I. Pis’mo G. I. Uspenskomu, 1892 g. [Semevskiy V. I. A letter to G. I. Uspensky, 1892]. Institut russkoy literatury [Institute of Russian Literature (IRLI)]. F. 313. Op. 3. L. 1 (in Russian).
12. Mel’gunov S. P. Pis’mo V. I. Semevskomu, noyabr’ 1911 g. [Mel’gunov S. P. A letter to V. I. Semevsky, November 1911]. Rossiyskiy gosudarstvennyy arkhiv literatury i iskussstva (RGALI) [Russian State Archive of Literature and Art]. F. 305. D. 92. L. 22 (in Russian).
13. Mel’gunov S. P. Pis’mo V. I. Semevskomu ot 14 sentyabrya 1912 g. [Mel’gunov S. P. A letter to V. I. Semevsky written on September 14, 1912]. Rossiyskiy gosudarstvennyy arkhiv literatury i iskussstva (RGALI) [Russian State Archive of Literature and Art]. F. 305. D. 93. L. 46. ob. (in Russian).
14. Mel’gunov S. P. Pis’mo V. I. Semevskomu ot 22 sentyabrya 1912 g. [Mel’gunov S. P. A letter to V. I. Semevsky written on September 22, 1912]. Rossiyskiy gosudarstvennyy arkhiv literatury i iskussstva (RGALI) [Russian State Archive of Literature and Art]. F. 305. D. 93. L. 50. ob. (in Russian).
15. Semevskiy V. I. Pis’mo S. P. Mel’gunovu ot 15 sentyabrya 1912 g. [Semevskiy V. I. A letter to S. P. Melgunov written on September 15, 1912]. Rossiyskiy gosudarstvennyy arkhiv literatury i iskussstva (RGALI) [Russian State Archive of Literature and Art]. F. 305. D. 696. L. 43−43. ob. (in Russian).
16. Sistematicheskiy ukazatel’ soderzhaniya “Golosa minuvshego” za 10 let (1913−1922) [Systematic index of the contents of “Golos minuvshego” for 10 years (1913−1922)]. Golos minuvshego − Voice of the Past, 1923, no. 1 (in Russian).
17. Sakulin P. N. Pis’mo V. I. Semevskomu ot 14 oktyabrya 1912 g. [Sakulin P. N. A letter to V. I. Semevsky written on October 14, 1912]. Rossiyskiy gosudarstvennyy arkhiv literatury i iskussstva (RGALI) [Russian State Archive of Literature and Art]. F. 444. Op. 1. D. 13. L. 2−3 (in Russian).
18. Ob izdanii v gorode Moskva zhurnala “Golos minuvshego” [About the publication of the magazine “Golos minuvshego” in Moscow]. Rossiyskiy gosudarstvennyy istoricheskiy arkhiv (RGIA) [Russian State Historical Archive]. F. 776. Op. 17. D. 473. L. 1−3 (in Russian).
19. Protokoly sobraniy chlenov izdatel'stva zhurnala “Golos minuvshego” [Records of meetings of the members of publishing house of the journal “Golos minuvshego”]. Arhiv Rossiyskoy akademii nauk [The Archive of the Russian Academy of Sciences]. F. 646. Op. 1. D. 2. L. 4−5 (in Russian).
20. Semevsky V. I. Pis’mo S. P. Mel’gunovu ot 15 fevralya 1916 g. [Semevsky V. I. A letter to S. P. Melgunov written on February 15, 1916]. Rossiyskiy gosudarstvennyy arkhiv literatury i iskussstva (RGALI) [Russian State Archive of Literature and Art]. F. 305. D. 728 (in Russian).
21. Semevskiy V. I. Pis’mo S. P. Mel’gunovu ot 30 yanvarya 1916 g. [Semevskiy V. I. A letter to S. P. Melgunov written on January 30, 1916]. Rossiyskiy gosudarstvennyy arkhiv literatury i iskussstva (RGALI) [Russian State Archive of Literature and Art]. F. 305. D. 727. L. 33−33. ob. (in Russian).
22. Semevskiy V. I. Pis’mo S. P. Mel’gunovu ot 26 iyulya 1914 g. [Semevskiy V. I. A letter to S. P. Melgunov written on July 26, 1914]. Rossiyskiy gosudarstvennyy arkhiv literatury i iskussstva (RGALI) [Russian State Archive of Literature and Art]. F. 305. D. 714. L. 63−64 (in Russian).
23. Kozlovskiy L. S. Germaniya i Pol’sha [Germany and Poland]. Golos minuvshego − Voice of the Past, 1914, no. 11, pp. 312−316 (in Russian).
24. Shreyder G. I. Iz istorii franko-ital’yanskikh otnosheniy [From the history of Franco-Italian relations]. Golos minuvshego − Voice of the Past, 1916, no. 5−6 (in Russian).
25. Pertsev V. N. Novye dannye o martovskikh dnyakh 1848 g. v Berline [New data on the days in March 1848 in Berlin]. Golos minuvshego − Voice of the Past, 1914, no. 6, pp. 255−260 (in Russian).
26. Tarle E. V. Chego nemtsy dolzhny trebovat’ ot russkikh? [What should the Germans demand from the Russians?]. Golos minuvshego − Voice of the Past, 1915, no. 2, pp. 263−269 (in Russian).
27. Mukhin O. N. Vlast’/Mif/Istoriografi ya: eshche raz o neobkhodimosti sravneniya v istoricheskom issledovanii [Power/Myth/Historiography: once again about the necessity of comparison in historical research]. Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo pedagogicheskogo universiteta – TSPU Bulletin, 2015, vol. 2 (155). pp. 84−91 (in Russian).
28. Mel’gunov S. P. Pis’mo V. I. Semevskomu ot 4 oktyabrya 1915 g. [Melgunov S. P. A letter to V. I. Semevsky written on October 4, 1915]. Rossiyskiy gosudarstvennyy arkhiv literatury i iskussstva (RGALI) [Russian State Archive of Literature and Art]. F. 305. D. 112 (in Russian).
29. Kizevetter A. A. Izbranie na tsarstvo M. F. Romanova [The election of M. F. Romanov to the Russian throne]. Golos minuvshego − Voice of the Past, 1913, no. 3, pp. 231−236 (in Russian).
30. Sokolov V. P’yanstvo na Rusi v epokhu pervykh Romanovykh i mery bor’by s nim [Drunkenness in Russia in the era of the fi rst Romanovs and measures to combat it]. Golos minuvshego − Voice of the Past, 1915, no. 11, pp. 105−118 (in Russian).
( 456.63 kB ) 
( 449.49 kB )
Issue: 5, 2016
Series of issue: Issue 5
Rubric: HISTORIOGRAPHY AND SOURCE STUDIES
Pages: 196 — 203
Downloads: 1396